The recruitment plateau, and the 3 things that will help you break though

If your billings haven’t grown in six months, let me be blunt: the problem isn’t the market.

The problem is you.

I know that might sting, but hear me out.

Recruitment is a performance business, and if your results have flatlined, it’s not because the market is against you, it’s because you’ve settled. You’ve found a level that feels comfortable, it pays your bills, funds your lifestyle, and doesn’t stretch you too far. And while that feels safe, here’s the truth:

In recruitment, staying the same is actually falling behind.

Markets shift. Competitors improve. Clients demand more. If you’re not actively pushing beyond your plateau, you’re leaving revenue, relationships, and opportunities on the table.

So how do you break through? Let’s explore.

Why Recruiters Plateau

Every recruiter hits a plateau at some stage. It’s normal. But staying there is where the danger lies.

Here are the most common reasons:

• Comfort. You’re hitting numbers that feel “good enough.” You’re not hungry in the same way you were at the start.

• Old habits. The strategies that once worked aren’t evolving. What landed clients a year ago might not cut through today.

• Busyness over productivity. You’re busy all day, updating the CRM, formatting CVs, scrolling job boards, but not necessarily doing the high-value activities that move the needle.

• 
  

The problem is, plateaus don’t feel like failure. They feel fine. That’s why they’re dangerous.

The Danger of Staying the Same

When you’re stuck at the same billing level, it’s easy to tell yourself you’re stable. But in reality, you’re slipping backwards.

• Markets shift. New competitors, new technology, new client expectations.

• Competitors improve. While you’re repeating what worked last year, they’re sharpening their processes, investing in training, and raising the bar.

• Clients demand more. The recruiter who brings consultative value will always beat the recruiter who just pushes CVs.

If you’re not growing, you’re shrinking, you just don’t see it yet.

How to Break Through a Billing Plateau

1. Audit Your Process

Start by looking at your inputs vs. outputs. Are you measuring the right things? For example:

• If you’re making 50 BD calls a week and booking no meetings, the issue isn’t volume — it’s approach.

• If CVs aren’t converting to interviews, it’s time to review your candidate matching or how you present profiles.

Don’t just track activity. Track outcomes. Look for patterns, then refine.

2. Cut “Busy Recruiter” Work

Recruiters love to be busy. But not all activity is equal. Some of the biggest time-wasters I see are:

• Spending hours formatting CVs instead of picking up the phone.

• Over-updating the CRM to the point where admin outweighs delivery.

• Living on job boards instead of nurturing pipelines.

Be ruthless. Ask yourself: “Does this activity directly bring me closer to a placement or a new client?” If not, cut it or delegate it.

3. Invest in Skills

The recruiters who grow aren’t just the hardest workers, they’re the ones who are constantly learning.

If your skills haven’t grown in the last six months, why would your billings?

Here are areas to focus on:

• Negotiation – turning more opportunities into revenue.

• Consultative selling – becoming a trusted advisor, not just a CV-pusher.

• Time management – protecting time for high-value activity.

Every skill you add compounds over time. The more you grow, the harder it becomes to plateau.

Don’t Just Work Harder, Work Smarter

Breaking through a billing plateau doesn’t mean doubling your hours or hammering the phones harder. It means being intentional.

Audit. Refine. Focus. Grow.

The recruiters who do this consistently aren’t just hitting targets, they’re building sustainable, long-term careers.

Ready to Grow Beyond Your Plateau?

If you’ve recognised yourself in this post, here’s the good news: you don’t have to figure it out alone.

This is exactly why I created The Recruiter Academy. It’s designed to help recruiters move past the comfort zone, sharpen their skills, and implement the strategies that lead to consistent growth.

Inside the Academy, we cover everything from building resilience and mastering BD calls to consultative client development and time management. It’s about giving you the tools, mindset, and structure to break through your plateau and keep growing.

So let me ask again: are you coasting, or are you growing?